How Much is Too Much (Taking too much in retirement)?


How much can you withdraw from your nest egg each year without running out of money before you die?

There is no single approach the industry has settled on yet, and probably won’t be due to conflicting interests between product based solutions versus a process based solution. This article (link at bottom) by Kelly Greene is a good summary on the state of thought to date.

My thought leadership on this is through a process based solution that incorporates your age, expected longevity statistics, and measures comparing what you are currently doing against what you should be doing in light of probabilities. This evaluation is redone each year to incorporate a now shorter lifespan because you have aged another year and updated portfolio values … in other words, a dynamic process that looks at the facts each year and one that does not depend on markets (since nobody knows what they will do tomorrow, let alone the rest of your life).

To get an idea about my approach to measuring sustainability over a person’s remaining lifetime, take a look at the sample decision matrix below.

Wall Street Journal | WEEKEND INVESTOR NOVEMBER 19, 2011

How Much Is Too Much? By KELLY GREENE

, , , , , , , , , , , , ,

7 Responses to How Much is Too Much (Taking too much in retirement)?

  1. Larry Frank, Sr. June 19, 2014 at 4:39 pm #

    Another blog that explains this further …


  1. My latest research published … | Better Financial Education Blog - April 4, 2012

    […] How might this research be applied to real people?  […]

  2. Emergency Procedures! | Better Financial Education Blog - August 3, 2012

    […] What should those already retired consider? […]

  3. Retirement Income Schools of Thought (part 2) | Better Financial Education Blog - March 6, 2013

    […] by an increasing withdrawal rate’s corresponding POF (percentage of simulations that fail). Portfolio values may be calculated at the beginning of each year to tell the retiree when their portfolio value should be of concern […]

  4. Just what should an annual checkup do for you? (Part 2) | Better Financial Education Blog - August 23, 2013

    […] What is a rational approach to decide when a slight reduction in spending is prudent? This blog on recognizing signals that suggest temporary reductions are in order is based on this published […]

  5. A Simple Retirement Income Process | Better Financial Education Blog - December 1, 2017

    […] Decision Rules are designed to recognize that markets go up and down all the time – so at what point during market declines should you make a decision and what decision should you make? When are you taking too much out of your portfolio? […]

  6. Retirement … the MOST important impact on your life | Better Financial Education Blog - December 17, 2017

    […] post-retiree not understand how to measure, evaluate, and if necessary adjust, retirement spending during retirement so that resources are sustainable. This has been a focus of many researchers, including myself, who […]

Leave a Reply